19 places matching
Open Manny's Tacos To Go
… ad takeout window — the highest-rated taco operation in Sarasota, run lean, priced fair, and known entirely by word of mouth.
Closed Indigenous Restaurant
… les Court arts district is the most acclaimed restaurant in Sarasota that tourists somehow keep missing. Chef Steve Phelps has been a James Beard Award semi-finalist, the menu changes with what local …
Closed La Violetta
La Violetta is an Italian restaurant disguised inside an office complex — you would drive past it a hundred times without stopping. Inside, the space is a cozy…
Open Garden of Joy
… of Joy serves Eastern European home cooking from a downtown Sarasota side street — pierogi, borscht, and stuffed cabbage at a ★4.7 that says grandma-grade. 240+ reviews, no website.
Open Tacos El Costeño
… Tuttle Avenue spot holding a ★4.8. Seafood tacos in Sarasota that locals actually rate. No website.
Closed Piccolo Italian Market & Deli
… Deli is the anchor of Gulf Gate's dining cluster and one of Sarasota's most reliable meals. An Italian market first, a deli second, and a restaurant sort of by accident — the sandwiches are made on fr …
Closed Fire Tacos
… afe — making it the second reason to find this hidden Sarasota side street. No website, 430+ reviews.
Closed Beauty of Sprouts
Beauty of Sprouts is Sarasota's ★4.7 vegan kitchen — a compact, warm room off downtown serving a rotating plant-based menu that converts skeptics. 250+ reviews, no website.
Open J.R.'s Old Packinghouse Cafe
… plates — and the music is the real draw. It's the most Sarasota-specific experience on this list.
Open Monk's Steamer Bar
Monk's is a Gulf Gate dive bar where Gulf oysters get shucked fresh at the counter. Sit, watch the shucker work, order a cold beer, repeat. It's the exact oppo…
Open Rincon Tolteca
Rincon Tolteca holds a ★4.6 across 500+ reviews from a South Tamiami Trail storefront — authentic Mexican plates at prices that embarrass the beach restaurants…
Open RomanSQ
RomanSQ does Roman-style pizza from focaccia dough — pillowy, thick, topped with combinations like potato-sausage or prosciutto-mozzarella — from a Gulf Gate s…
Open Tripletail Seafood & Spirits
Tripletail Seafood & Spirits handles fresh Gulf fish with an inventive cocktail program at prices that make no sense for the quality level. In Gulf Gate's dini…
Open Bob's Train
Bob's Train on Fruitville Road serves classic burgers and American lunch fare out of four restored Pullman train cars filled with circus memorabilia. It's quir…
Open Stroke's Seafood
Stroke's Seafood fries North Sarasota's fish the neighborhood way — ★4.5 across 350 reviews on North Osprey, a world away from the marina-priced seafood the city shows visitors. No website.
Open Tortas Locas & Bakery
… n pan dulce in Gillespie Park — ★4.4, 250+ reviews, and Sarasota's only serious torta specialist. No website.
Closed Crager's Restaurant
Crager's is the North Trail's quaint all-American diner — 1,400+ reviews at ★4.3, down-to-earth plates, and the airport-corridor location that keeps it a local…
Open Guadalupana
Guadalupana is Sarasota's no-frills taqueria on North Washington Boulevard — the one the local Mexican community actually eats at, with nearly 600 reviews and no website in sight.
Closed Don Beto Jaimes Restaurant
Don Beto Jaimes cooks rancho-style Mexican on Sarasota's northern edge — named for its founder, run like a family dinner table, rated ★4.3 by nearly 300 people who found it anyway. No website.