★★★★★
Best pizza in St. Pete, hands down. The white pizza is legendary and the cheesesteak sub is the real deal — feels like a slice of Brooklyn on 49th Street.
Pizza · Disston Heights · St. Petersburg
Tobys Original Little
Italy Pizza
01
The place
Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza is a family-owned pizza and Italian restaurant at 3523 49th Street N in the Disston Heights neighborhood of St. Petersburg, Florida. The shop has served hand-tossed New York–style pizza, cheesesteaks, and oven-baked subs over the counter since the 1980s. It holds a 4.7-star Google rating across more than 4,400 reviews. Service is counter-order with limited indoor seating and takeout-focused operations. Specialties include the white pizza, the Philly cheesesteak sub, and stromboli. The kitchen accommodates standard vegetarian options on pizzas and subs. Street parking is available directly in front of the shop, and delivery is offered through third-party platforms.
Tucked into a small storefront on 49th Street N in Disston Heights, Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza has been a St. Petersburg neighborhood staple for decades. The vibe is purely old-school New York pizzeria: a counter, a few tables, a stack of pizza boxes, and the smell of garlic and oregano the second you walk in. With 4,400-plus Google reviews averaging 4.7 stars, locals consistently rank it among the best pizza shops on the west side of the city.
Order a classic cheese slice or go full pie with the white pizza, loaded with ricotta, mozzarella, and garlic. The Philly cheesesteak sub gets called out repeatedly in reviews, and the stromboli and meatball parm sub are crowd favorites. Wings, garlic knots, and baked ziti round out a deep menu, and prices stay refreshingly low — most subs and large pies land well under $20.
Tobys is takeout- and counter-service focused, with a small dining area for eat-in. No reservations are taken. Free street parking is available right out front on 49th Street N, and delivery is offered through DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub. The shop is not formally pet-friendly indoors, but takeout makes it easy to grab a pie and head to a nearby park.
4.7★ on Google with 4,400+ reviews
Family-owned Disston Heights staple since the 1980s
New York–style hand-tossed pizza
White pizza with ricotta and roasted garlic (top-mentioned)
What to expect
Expect a no-frills, counter-order pizzeria where the focus is the food, not the décor. Slices come out fast, pies take 15–20 minutes, and the staff is famously friendly with regulars. Cash and cards accepted. Best for takeout, casual dine-in, and family pickup orders.
Then come for the photos
03
The shop, in frames
Sponsored · Florida Hidden Spots
04
What people are saying
★★★★★
Family-owned and it shows. Friendly counter staff, fair prices, and the stromboli is massive. We've been coming for years and it hasn't slipped once.
★★★★★
Old-school pizza joint with no pretension. Crust has the perfect chew, sauce is bright, and the meatball parm is one of the best subs I've had in Florida.
05
Frequently asked
Does Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza take reservations?
No — Tobys is a counter-order pizzeria and does not take reservations. Walk-ins for dine-in and takeout are standard.
Is Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza dog/pet friendly?
There is no formal pet-friendly seating indoors. The shop is takeout-focused, so picking up an order and heading to a nearby park is the easiest option for pet owners.
Where do I park near Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza?
Free street parking is available directly in front of the shop on 49th Street N, with additional spots along the side streets in the Disston Heights neighborhood.
What are the most popular dishes at Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza?
Most-mentioned items in reviews include the white pizza, the Philly cheesesteak sub, the stromboli, and the meatball parmesan sub. Large cheese pies and garlic knots are also crowd favorites.
What are Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza's hours?
Tobys is generally open 11am–10pm Monday through Thursday, 11am–11pm Friday and Saturday, and 11am–10pm Sunday. Confirm current hours by calling (727) 522-2717.
Does Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza offer takeout or delivery?
Yes. Takeout is the primary service style, and delivery is available through DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub within the St. Petersburg delivery zone.
06
Closest spots by distance
Other places to fold into the same trip — measured straight-line from Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza.
