Timoti's Seaf
Timoti's
The place
Counter-service wild-caught seafood in the Five Points neighborhood of Riverside — the go-to local seafood spot for the Riverside and Avondale crowd. Fresh, unpretentious, sourced locally with poke bowls and classic baskets alongside the city's best fish tacos.
Timoti's Seafood Shak occupies a small storefront on Park Street in the heart of Five Points, Jacksonville's bohemian commercial strip in Riverside. It's counter-service, it closes in the afternoon, and it sources its seafood wild-caught and locally when possible — a different set of priorities than most seafood restaurants in the city, and one that shows in what ends up on the tray.
The fish tacos are the item most locals lead with: fresh fish in a corn tortilla with slaw and house sauces, the kind of taco that doesn't require any explanation because it simply tastes right. The shrimp and fish baskets are the straightforward route — fried well, not greasy, portions that don't disappoint. The poke bowls are the contemporary option if you want something lighter. The clam chowder is made in-house and worth ordering on cooler days.
Timoti's fills a specific gap in the Riverside and Avondale dining landscape: it's the neighborhood's seafood option, unpretentious and community-embedded, and the Park Street location puts it within walking distance of the residential blocks that define what Five Points actually is. It's not a destination restaurant. It's what you eat when you live nearby and want good seafood without having to drive to Mayport.
What to expect
Fast-casual counter-service seafood on Park Street in Five Points. Order at the counter, grab a seat inside or at the small outdoor area. The fish tacos and shrimp baskets are the go-to orders. Limited afternoon hours — check before going for dinner. Parking on the side streets off Park is free and usually available.
The shop, in frames
What people are saying
Frequently asked
Is Timoti's good for a sit-down dinner?
Is the seafood actually local?
Where should I park?
Closest spots by distance
Other places to fold into the same trip — measured straight-line from Timoti's Seafood Shak.
