★★★★★
Best New York–style pizza in St. Pete, hands down. The Sicilian square is the move — crispy bottom, soft inside, perfect cheese edge. Service was quick and friendly.
Italian Restaurants · Crescent Lake · St. Petersburg
Jay
Luigi
01
The place
Jay Luigi is an Italian restaurant and pizzeria at 3201 4th St N in the Crescent Lake area of St. Petersburg, Florida. The menu centers on New York–style pizza, hand-tossed Sicilian squares, classic red-sauce pasta, and oversized stromboli. The dining room is casual and family-friendly with a full bar pouring Italian wines, Aperol spritzes, and craft cocktails. Takeout, delivery, and dine-in are available, and large parties can be accommodated with notice. The restaurant rates 4.7 stars across 944 Google reviews and is regularly cited among the top pizza spots in St. Petersburg. Parking is on-site in a dedicated lot off 4th Street North.
Jay Luigi sits on the busy 4th Street North corridor just north of downtown St. Pete, tucked between the Crescent Lake and Historic Old Northeast neighborhoods. The space leans into red-checkered tablecloths and warm lighting, with a bar pouring Italian wines and Aperol spritzes alongside cold draft beer. It's the kind of neighborhood Italian spot that locals return to weekly — equal parts date-night-friendly and family-friendly.
The kitchen is best known for its New York–style pizza by the pie or the slice, but the Sicilian square and stromboli get nearly as much love in reviews. Beyond pizza, the menu runs through chicken parmesan, baked ziti, lasagna, eggplant rollatini, garlic knots, and shareable antipasto boards. Save room for tiramisu or cannoli.
Reservations aren't typically needed but are accepted for larger parties — call ahead on Friday and Saturday nights. There's a dedicated parking lot on-site off 4th Street North, and takeout plus third-party delivery through DoorDash and Uber Eats are both popular. A small outdoor patio area is dog-friendly when seated outside.
New York–style pizza and Sicilian squares
Full bar with Italian wines and Aperol spritzes
Dine-in, takeout, and delivery
Dedicated on-site parking lot
What to expect
Expect a lively, casual Italian-American dining room with a bar, generous portions, and a pizza menu that draws repeat visitors from across St. Pete. Plan on a short wait at peak weekend hours; takeout orders move fast. Follow @jayluigistpete on Instagram for daily specials and weekend pizza features.
Then come for the photos
03
The shop, in frames
Sponsored · Florida Hidden Spots
04
What people are saying
★★★★★
We come here at least twice a month. The chicken parm is massive and the garlic knots are addictive. Cozy vibe, great wine list, and the staff remembers regulars.
★★★★★
Stromboli is the size of a football and could feed a family. Tiramisu was excellent. Easy parking right out front and they handled our group of eight without a hiccup.
06
Frequently asked
Does Jay Luigi take reservations?
Reservations aren't typically required for small parties, but they are accepted and recommended for groups of six or more, especially on Friday and Saturday evenings. Call (727) 390-8883 to book ahead.
Is Jay Luigi dog friendly?
Yes — well-behaved dogs are welcome at the small outdoor patio seating area. Pets are not permitted in the indoor dining room per Florida health code.
Where do I park near Jay Luigi?
Jay Luigi has its own dedicated parking lot directly off 4th Street North at 32nd Avenue. Additional street parking is available on nearby side streets in the Crescent Lake neighborhood.
What are the most popular dishes at Jay Luigi?
Google reviewers most often mention the New York–style cheese pizza, the Sicilian square, pepperoni stromboli, chicken parmesan, garlic knots, and the tiramisu.
What are Jay Luigi's hours?
Jay Luigi is open Sunday through Thursday from 11am to 9pm, and Friday and Saturday from 11am to 10pm. Hours may vary on major holidays.
Does Jay Luigi offer takeout or delivery?
Yes — takeout is available by calling (727) 390-8883 or ordering through the website at jayluigi.com. Delivery is offered through DoorDash and Uber Eats within the St. Petersburg area.
How can I follow Jay Luigi for daily specials?
Follow @jayluigistpete on Instagram for daily specials, new menu features, and weekend pizza updates.
07
Closest spots by distance
Other places to fold into the same trip — measured straight-line from Jay Luigi.
08
From Instagram
@jayluigistpete