Local Guide · Jacksonville

Pizza in Jacksonville

From Detroit-style squares to Neapolitan pies — the locals' guide to the best pizza spots across Florida.

3 spots 4.6 avg rating 3 neighborhoods

Jacksonville's pizza scene is shaped less by a single dominant style than by a corridor of independent shops running along the St. Johns River, with Riverside, San Marco, and Murray Hill forming the core. The city leans Neapolitan-influenced at the higher end — wood-fired ovens, blistered cornicione, San Marzano-forward sauce — while the older neighborhood joints hold the line on hand-tossed New York rounds sold by the slice. Carmines Pie House in Springfield and Moon River Pizza in Murray Hill are the touchstones for that East Coast slice tradition, while V Pizza built its reputation on the certified Neapolitan side before expanding the Sidecar concept next door.

When you're picking from the three below, pay attention to oven type and serving format, because they signal what the kitchen is actually optimizing for. A by-the-slice counter means the dough has been resting long enough to reheat well; a whole-pie-only menu usually means the cook wants you eating it within four minutes of the peel. Locals also know the Murray Hill and Riverside spots get tight on Friday after 7 p.m., and that parking on King Street and Park Street is the real friction point, not the wait list.

Common questions about pizza in Jacksonville
Which Jacksonville neighborhood has the best pizza?
Riverside, Murray Hill, and San Marco are the three neighborhoods most associated with Jacksonville's independent pizza scene. Murray Hill leans toward classic New York-style slice shops like Moon River, Riverside has a mix of Neapolitan and modern wood-fired spots, and San Marco trends slightly more upscale with sit-down dining rooms.
What style of pizza is Jacksonville known for?
Jacksonville does not have a single signature regional style the way New Haven or Detroit do. The local scene splits between hand-tossed New York-style slices at older neighborhood shops and certified Neapolitan pies at newer wood-fired restaurants. V Pizza helped popularize the Neapolitan side locally starting in the 2010s.
Are Jacksonville pizza places open late?
Most independent pizzerias in Riverside and Murray Hill close between 9 and 10 p.m. on weeknights, with later hours on Friday and Saturday — typically until 11 p.m. or midnight. Carmines Pie House and slice-format shops near the bar districts tend to stay open the latest. Always confirm hours directly, as schedules shift seasonally.
Do Jacksonville pizza spots take reservations?
Most counter-service and slice shops in Murray Hill and Riverside are walk-in only. Larger sit-down restaurants like V Pizza locations and Sidecar may accept reservations or use waitlist apps for parties of six or more. For Friday and Saturday dinner, arriving before 6:30 p.m. is the most reliable way to avoid a wait.
Sort:
03 — By Neighborhood

Pizza in each corner of Jacksonville